.

Following formerly done Cushion review, I am reviewing pen eyeliner this time

.

.

.

Innisfree powerproof pen liner
CLIO waterproof brush liner kill black
TONYMOLY perfect eyes long kinny gel pen liner

.

This reviews compares these 3 items.

.

I usually use pen liner more often than pencil, liquid, or gel eyeliner.
It is a very important item that makes my eyeline.

.

I used to try as many products as I could and buy.
But thesedays I buy a lot of products from Korean road shops and decide my item :)

.

Despite reasonable prices, there are many products that performs better than
expensive brands from department stores.

.

So I love to find high-quality products from road shops :)

.

Let's get down to business!

.

.

.

Took 3 items together.
Innisfree powerproof pen liner(left), CLIO waterproof brush liner kill black(middle),

and TONYMOLY perfect eyes long kinny gel pen liner on the right.

.

.

.

First I looked on Innisfree product. External appearance is simple(white) and the brush has very thin sponge tip.
I am sure it will draw delicate parts without difficulty.
Not to let the eyeliner dry quickly, cover is double cover :)

.

.

.

Second, CLIO product. Dark grey color with soft pearl outside.
Brush is hard enough and elastic.
It's a pen-brush type. So I was concerned about brush split.
But since it's elastic, it won't easily be. Personally, It has most trustworthy cover among 3 products lol

.

.

.

Lastly, TONYMOLY. Normal black double cover.
I liked the soft brush it has. but a bit worried of its too-softness.

.

.

.

Color of the products.
Among them, Innisfree had best color representation.
Deep color with just one touch amazed me.
CLIO was normal.
and TONYMOLY showed not enough coloring with one touch.

.

.

.

Since it is hard to judge the color on back of hand, I did makeup with eyeliners.

.

.

CLIO on eye mekeup and back of hand.
on order of rubbed with finger, with toner, with emulsion, with remover from left.
Little amount come out when rubbed with hand.
Easily washed off with toner, emulsion, and remover.

.

.

.

Innisfree. I like the color representation. but it is oily and glossy. Doesn't absorb well.
No sign of spreading when rubbed with hand.
Easily cleaned with toner, emulsion, and remover on cotton tips.
Recommend for people with many oil around eyes.

.

.

.

TONYMOLY lastly. Weak color made me disappointed a bit.
But its sustainability was greatest among 3.
Was not removed well with toner and emulsion.
But it was well removed with remover.

.

.

.

Totally, product you can use without difficulty is CLIO.
and Innisfree then TONYMOLY.

.

.

Coloring was Innisfree> CLIO> TONYMOLY.

.

Sustainability
TONYMOLY> Innisfree> CLIO
unexpectedly..

.

Lastly, all 3 products were well remove by remover.
and there were no remains.

.

I said good things and bad things of the products since it's a comparison.

.

But all of them enjoys good comments due to great performance with reasonable prices.
So I feel like I am going to use these all :)

.

This review is very subjective to my personal interest.
So try to pick the products according to your skin type and eye shape. :)

.

.

Innisfree
POWERPROOF BRUSH LINER 0.6g Real black

CLIO
New Born Kill Black Water-proof Brush Liner 0.55ml

TONYMOLY
New Perfect Eyes Long Kinny Gel Pen Liner 0.6g