I bought the brown one as I wanted a more natural look and it get's the job done.

I wouldn't say I don't like it, as it stays a pretty decent amount of time in your eyes if you don't touch them a lot, but when I do my eyeliner sometimes I'm not sure if I've done it right, as the formula is not completely opaque (?. It depends on the light, but I think it's just me that I'm still not used to the fact that it's not black.

I really like the color and it's  easy to use, so I really recommend it to people who are starting with makeup.